As a civilian firearms enthusiast, you might wonder are military-grade red dot sights worth the money or is just buying a fantasy without any real practical use.
As with any significant firearm accessory purchase, do your research, consider your specific needs, and if possible, try before you buy.
NEVER go into debt for any of this if it's just something you WANT over NEED.
Intended Use VS Just Collecting
Remember, the "best" sight is the one that works best for you and your specific needs. What works for a professional shooter or soldier might not be the ideal choice for your civilian use and you are paying for it.
We all know that some users just buy what they need, and some will by anything that has the mil-spec label on it because it's cool.
Some users just hoard gun items, and just let them collect dust without ever really putting in the time to train with them.
Cost vs. Value
It's no secret that military-grade sights often come with a higher price tag than basic civilian models. However, it's important to consider the long-term value.
There are optics I will NEVER recommend for example the new Sig ROMEO 9T that costs over $4K, and there is nothing significant about it rather than just selling a fantasy if you're a civilian.
Value considerations:
- Durability: Less likely to need replacement.
- Versatility: Can be used across multiple firearms and scenarios.
- Performance: May improve your shooting abilities.
- Resale value: High-end sights often retain value well.
When I first invested in a military-grade sight, the cost gave me pause because they can be even more expensive than the gun itself. However, after years of reliable use across multiple firearms and seeing the advanced of red dot technology, where budget options are as good as a high end red dot.
When the demand is high, the price drops overtime.
You absolutely do not need to buy a high end $500 to $900 optic for every one of your guns. Brands like Holosun is making many high quality optics available to the general public.
Built to Last
Military-grade red dot sights are designed to withstand extreme conditions to hold zero.
They're built to handle the rough and tumble of combat situations, which means they're more than capable of handling civilian use.
Key durability features include:
- Shock resistance: These sights can withstand heavy recoil and impacts without losing zero.
- Water resistance: Many are waterproof, not just water-resistant.
- Fog proof: Sealed optics prevent internal fogging in varying temperatures.
- Scratch-resistant lenses: High-quality glass with protective coatings.
I once dropped my rifle with a military-grade sight Aimpoint Micro. It's a $850 optic and yes it still gets scratched, but it also maintained its zero along with a high quality mount.
This level of durability gives you peace of mind, knowing your optic will perform when you need it most.
Reticle Options
Military-grade sights often offer more sophisticated reticle options than basic civilian models. These can provide advantages for different shooting scenarios.
Here are some options to consider:
I've found that having multiple reticle options in one sight is incredibly versatile so I can switch among them.
For close-range shooting, I use a larger center dot for quick target acquisition without cluttering up the field of view. When I need more precision at longer ranges, I can switch to a smaller dot. This flexibility is a significant advantage of military-grade sights.
Long Battery Life
While consumer-grade sights used to last just a few thousand hours, but now they can last as long as some of these top-tier military sights. 50000 hours is the standard, and many can even last up to 100000 hours with shakeawake and solar technology.
So between a civilian budget grade red dot sight and a military grade red dot sight, the battery life performance is something both options can provide.
So you can just leave the optic on without having to worry about the battery at all. It's just one less thing to think about.
Dot Clarity
Dot clarity is something that has to do with the user's vision. Many red dot sights whether they are civilian grade or military, they all appear blurry to users with astigmatism.
The most popular dot options are 1 MOA, 2 MOA, 3 MOA, and 6 MOA. The smaller the dot the more precise it is to aim, but the emitter will create a starburst in the field of the view if the user has trouble with refractive error in his or her eye.
The bigger the dot, the easier is to see the round dot appear, but the caveat is that if the dot brightness is cranked up too high, it can obscure the dot and creates a lot of emitter glare, and if the user's vision is bad, then the dot will still appear blurry.
I have used many red dot sights in the past, and I say fixing your eyes is the best thing to do if you want to see the reticle clearly instead of buying optics that are promising better dot clarity.
Clarity and Field of View
Most optics have clear glasses unless you want to nitpick things that aren't really noticeable such as lens edge clarity or tint. Lens tint can make the field of view slightly darker, but sometimes it doesn't make sense when some users complain about the tint, but they also wear sunglasses, which can make the field of view appear darker anyway.
As far as field of view goes, many civilian and military grade optics offer a wide selection of red dot sights. In the recent years there is a push towards large window optics for pistol and rifle applications.
A wider window just gives the shooter more room to see the dark and to find the dot. Some of the most popular options are the Trijicon SRO, Holosun 507 Comp, Holosun AEMS MAX and many others just like them.
Parallax
While military grade optics claim they have 100% free parallax. This is completely false, and it's just a marketing message to get people to buy their products.
Parallax free means that the shooter doesn't have to directly align the eye behind the optic to aim. However, as the target plane is 10 yards or closer, the parallax shift is more apparent, and the point of aim and point of impact significantly changes.
Most civilian and military optics will have CLOSE ENOUGH 100% parallax free performance, but it's never 100%. In fact, no optics ever have 100% parallax free.
Weight and Size Considerations
While military-grade sights are built to be tough, manufacturers also understand the importance of keeping weight and size manageable. The same goes for civilian red dot sights.
Today, the most durable material for a red dot product is 7075 T6 aluminum. It strikes the perfect balance between strength and weight.
Despite their durability, they're often not much larger or heavier than budget options. Since many red dot sights are well made these days without costing too much money. Most red dot sights with a good mount will weigh about 0.3 to 0.4 lbs
Mounting Accessories
Red dot mount options for civilian and military optics are very similar. As long as the footprint matches, then all of them will fit.
However, not all mounts are created equal. A poor mount can make a top tier red dot lose zero if it can't maintain the zero or if it always gets loose.
Optic height can also affect shooting performance. While some shooters prefer something like a 1.93" tall mount to reduce neck strain while shooting a rifle.
Brightness Settings
Both Military-grade sights and civilian optics often feature a wide range of brightness settings, but not all products.
Right now there are 4 popular options:
Holosun SCS 320 with a light sensor technology without using any battery
Some red dot sights just can't afford to have the brightness reticle setting because it will drain the battery faster, and not last as long. Some offer very high brightness setting to work under a sunny day and bright weapon light to ensure the dot is visible.
Some can be too bright when operating in low light conditions, which can make the field of view utterly annoying to look through, and blind the shooter
In the recent years, technology is advancing to make automatic dot adjustment a thing based on the target plane's lighting condition to perfectly adjust the dot brightness.
One of the most advanced products is the Trijicon RMR HD.
Some uses light sensor technology to adjust the brightness like the Holosun SCS.
The auto-adjustment feature on my current sight has been a revelation. Whether I'm shooting indoors, outdoors, or in changing light conditions, the dot is always at the perfect brightness.
This feature allows you to focus on your target rather than fiddling with brightness controls.